Navigating a Senior Leadership Dispute in a Growing Business
A growing, owner-led business in the commercial fit-out and interiors sector with approximately 100 employees.
The Challenge
The leadership team approached Rinew Legal at the outset of a highly sensitive situation involving the suspension, investigation and disciplinary process of a senior individual.
This wasn’t a typical employment issue. The individual was also a Managing Director, shareholder and statutory director, meaning the situation crossed into corporate governance and shareholder considerations as well as employment law.
For the leadership team, the issue quickly became complex.
It involved someone at the very top of the organisation, carried clear reputational risk and created a level of internal disruption the business had never experienced before. At the same time, the company was continuing to grow and the leadership team needed to stay focused on running the business.
Handling the process incorrectly could have create significant financial exposure. From an early stage, it was anticipated that the situation could lead to an unfair dismissal claim in the Employment Tribunal.
The business needed clear guidance, reassurance and structural approach to navigating an unfamiliar and high-stakes situation.
Our Role
Rinew Legal was brought in at the very beginning of the process.
That early involvement meant we were able to help shape the approach from the outset and guide the leadership team through each stage as the situation developed.
We supported the business through:
- The suspension and investigation process
- The disciplinary hearing and appeal
- The management of communications throughout the matter
- The alignment of employment and corporate considerations
Just as importantly, we became a consistent point of contact for the leadership team. This provided clarity at each stage of the process and allowed decisions to be made confidently, knowing the wider legal and commercial implications had been considered.
In situations involving senior individuals, the legal process is only part of the challenge. There are also internal dynamics, reputational considerations and leadership relationships to manage. Our role was to help the client navigate all of those factors while maintaining a fair and defensible process.
The Tribunal Claim
As anticipated, the individual issued a claim for unfair dismissal in the Employment Tribunal.
Because we had been involved throughout the earlier stages, we already had a detailed understanding of the evidence and the reasoning behind the decisions that had been taken. This preparation was critical once the matter moved into formal litigation.
The case itself was substantial. It involved a tribunal bundle of more than 2,000 pages, complex senior-level issues and an aggressive litigant.
Our role was to manage the litigation while continuing to support the leadership team behind the scenes, ensuring the case was thoroughly prepared and the business remained focused on its day-to-day operations.
"This was a situation that we had never dealt with before, and it quickly became a major distraction for the leadership team. Rinew Legal provided clear guidance from the outset, managed the process calmly and professionally, and gave us the confidence that we were handling everything correctly. Having that support made a huge difference to the business."
The Outcome
As anticipated, the individual issued a claim for unfair dismissal in the Employment Tribunal.
Because we had been involved throughout the earlier stages, we already had a detailed understanding of the evidence and the reasoning behind the decisions that had been taken. This preparation was critical once the matter moved into formal litigation.
The case itself was substantial. It involved a tribunal bundle of more than 2,000 pages, complex senior-level issues and an aggressive litigant.
Our role was to manage the litigation while continuing to support the leadership team behind the scenes, ensuring the case was thoroughly prepared and the business remained focused on its day-to-day operations.
Need similar support?
If you're dealing with a sensitive employee issue or want ongoing employment law support as your business grows, our team can help.
Learn more about our ongoing support model on our Subscription Services page.