Employers, HR professionals and legal advisers are increasingly noting a shift in how workplace issues are raised and handled. One of the most notable developments is the rising use of AI as an assistive tool – from drafting emails to preparing tribunal claims.
A recent example, where an AI-driven employment law service reportedly helped secure a £30,000 settlement, illustrates just how rapidly this field is evolving.
AI can be a useful everyday tool for anyone. But in employment law, it raises a more complex question: what happens when employees start to rely on AI not just for support, but for legal advice and representation?
A New Type of Claimant
As AI tools become more accessible, employers might encounter a different kind of claimant – someone who is more informed, more confident, and often quicker to escalate issues.
In some cases, AI can assist employees to:
- Test potential claims quickly and at low cost
- Draft grievance or pre-action correspondence in minutes
- Engage in settlement discussions without formal legal representation
This accessibility is likely to lead to an increase in formal complaints and disputes, especially as employees turn to free or low-cost AI tools for immediate guidance.
However, a balance must be struck. While some AI-generated claims may be well-structured, others could rely on outdated or misinterpreted legal principles, adding additional friction in an already sensitive situation.
What This Means for Employers
In practical terms, employers may begin to see:
- More legally framed grievances
- More detailed and technical correspondence
- Earlier escalation of workplace issues
- More assertive communication during formal processes
AI-generated content can also reveal inconsistencies or gaps in internal processes more quickly, emphasising the importance of clear, well-documented procedures.
Therefore, organisations need to adapt by:
- Ensuring policies and procedures are up to date and consistently applied
- Maintaining clear and thorough documentation
- Seeking early legal input where a potential issue could develop into a claim
AI Hallucinations and Legal Risk
A key challenge with AI is reliability. The so-called “hallucinations” – where systems produce confident but incorrect information – remain a known issue. This means a claim could seem credible on the surface, referencing legislation or case law, but upon closer inspection, may rest on flawed reasoning.
For employers and HR teams, this adds an extra layer of complexity. It is no longer just about assessing the substance of a claim, but also about understanding whether the underlying arguments are legally sound.
Regulation and the Wider Impact
Unlike solicitors, who are regulated by bodies such as the Solicitors Regulation Authority, many AI tools currently operate without clear oversight.
This presents risks on both sides:
- Employees may rely on inaccurate advice, potentially weakening valid claims or pursuing unmeritorious ones;
- Employers may face an increase in poorly grounded but confidently presented disputes.
At a system level, there could also be broader implications. The increased use of AI might contribute to higher volumes of claims within an already stretched tribunal system, raising questions around efficiency and fairness.
A Shifting Landscape
The challenge for employers is no longer just about managing legal risk in the traditional sense. It involves responding to a workforce that is more digitally enabled, where access to information, accurate or not, is immediate.
For HR teams and business leaders, this underscores the importance of clarity, consistency, and early intervention.
—
The reported £30,000 AI-assisted settlement might be one of the first high-profile examples, but it is unlikely to be the last. AI will continue to influence how workplace disputes are raised, understood, and resolved. The key for employers is to stay ahead of this shift, ensuring that processes, policies, and advice evolve in tandem.
At Rinew Legal, we support organisations in navigating these changes with clear, practical guidance that help teams respond confidently in an increasingly complex employment landscape.